At NADA many exhibitors hyped their digital retailing solutions to support online vehicle transactions. While no one has cracked the code for a complete, seamless online transaction, there are several great solutions that provide enough functionality to meet consumer demands. After all, consumers are not asking for a 100% “digital process."


What consumers rely on most from a digital experience is to cut through the traditional 'shishcamunga' at auto dealerships, and to experience the same transparent, consumer-driven process they are accustomed to elsewhere.


I saw this at AutoNation years ago, where its call-center-enabled AutoNationDirect delivered amazing customer satisfaction, even when the process required pdf contracts and scheduled phone appointments. Most dealers have better technology today, but the question is, do they have the will to be truly transparent?


The major remaining hurdles to Digital Retailing are not technical, they are cultural. Many dealers still believe transparency and profitability are in conflict. So, they resist the business model changes—e.g. transparent pricing across the four-square and pay plan changes—required to enable scale digital retailing.


Without the ability to see real, market-based prices on the vehicle purchased and trade-in, consumers will not transact, regardless of how slick the UI is.


In addition, consumers will need better information about F&I products and pricing to purchase online. They will need unbiased guidance to navigate their many choices in a very complex transaction. What they don't want or need is advice steered by pay plan considerations.


Dealers first need to commit to transparency, then figure out a business model and technology that results in the highest profit from a transparent process. I believe that those dealers who embrace change the fastest, will be rewarded long-term in a new market.


Don’t take my word for it. “The Market” has already issued its initial verdict. What does “The Market” think about how digital retailing will unfold? I think the relative market value of Carvana and the leading public auto retailers tells an interesting story.


At the end of January Carvana’s market cap equaled nearly $6 billion, nearly the same as AutoNation and Penske combined. That suggests two things. First, “The Market” sees tremendous value creation potential from digital retailing—hence Carvana’s valuation. Second, “The Market” does not believe today’s auto sales leaders will lead the way—hence the gap with traditional retailers.


The key to closing that gap is not to focus on technology, but consumer experience.  When the bath-robed Millennial from Carvana’s inaugural ads, said “that didn’t suck” he was referring to the overall experience, not solely the digital UI/UX.


Every dealer has the capacity to close the gap, but it starts with a commitment to transparency, because technology-driven opacity will still “suck."

Views: 135


You need to be a member of to add comments!


Comment by Marco Antonio R. Botelho on February 19, 2019 at 9:18am

Absolutely. I would say that the lack of transparency is sadly also seen in the after sales, with some dealerships sonegating info. during vehicle diagnosis that suposedly could cause customer defections.

Latest Activity

Sally Whitesell posted a blog post
23 hours ago
Eric Damiani posted a blog post


Cargurus, I have notice that because Carvana will provide free delivery to many area, they now show…See More
Bill Wittenmyer posted a video

Freebie Friday: How Do You Stay Motivated?

Bill Wittenmyer shares tips on how dealership personnel can stay motivated in this edition of Freebie Friday.
Andy Church posted a video

Profit By Action Quick Tip: Importance of Up To Date Warranties & Recalls

Andy Church shares why keeping up with warranties and recalls can increase profitability in this Quick Tip.
Scot Eisenfelder posted a video

Razor & Razor Blade Models for Dealerships: Part 1

Affinitiv CEO & Executive Chairman Scot Eisenfelder shares why dealerships should pay attention to the razor and razor blade models for their stores.
Jim Flint posted a blog post
Yogesh Sashi posted blog posts
Asad Shoaib posted a blog post

The Importance of Vehicle Electrical System Repair

The severity of the issue with your vehicle electrical system is dependent on the root causes and…See More
Ryan Holman posted a blog post

Let’s Know The Benefit Of Window Tint Films For Cars

Global warming has become a matter of concern nowadays. It has been showing its impact on the…See More
Walter McNulty posted a video


Big Event North Carolina
Walter McNulty posted a status
"Having a great event in North Carolina."
Veronica Dunford posted a blog post
Chris Miller posted a blog post
Erik S. Nachbahr posted a video

Is Your Computer Software Costing You Millions Due to Your Employees?

Erik Nachbahr explains why employees could be endangering dealerships through improper use of computer software.
Dave Anderson's 2 blog posts were featured
Anne Fleming's blog post was featured

How Did We Do?

As a part of your toolbox for improving the customer experience and reputation building, reviews…See More
Dave Anderson posted a blog post

The “Wow” is Worth It!

Author Joe Calloway described a “brand” well in his book Never by Chance: “A brand is defined as a…See More
Anne Fleming posted a blog post

How Did We Do?

As a part of your toolbox for improving the customer experience and reputation building, reviews…See More
Black Book posted blog posts

Get Newsletter

© 2019   Created by DealerELITE.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service