Tennessee Gets a New Recall Law and Consumers Aren’t Happy!

January 1 saw the enactment of Tennessee House Bill 141, to the collective groan of consumers. In a nutshell, this new law prevents consumers from suing car dealers if they purchase a used vehicle with an open safety recall, as long as it was disclosed, and the customer signed off on that disclosure.

 

For many dealerships the law doesn’t appear to be a dramatic shift from what already takes place.  So, what is different about it, causing it to draw the rage of consumer protection groups and organizations, fearing Tennessee will become the nation’s dumping ground for recalled vehicles?

 

While every other state in the nation has consumer protection laws that require recall safety disclosures upon the sale of an affected vehicle, Tennessee is the first state that will indemnify a dealer post-sale, IF, at the time of purchase, the consumer was notified of the existing safety recall.

 

While other states have tried to pass similar laws, all have failed ---- until now.

 

Lobbyists for the automotive industry are celebrating the law’s passage. However, in my opinion, there’s not much to cheer about. Let me explain: Certainly, as a car dealer, avoiding liability through the legal and democratic process is, understandably, a reason to cheer -- that I understand. Nobody wants to get sued. However, this bill was passed at the eleventh hour and attached to other legislation. As a result, consumer reaction so far is to feel tricked and slighted by state legislators, the automotive industry and lobbyists.  

 

Sadly, this type of action just reinforces the old stereotype that car dealers can’t be trusted. There is also concern that dealers in the other 49 states will begin dumping used vehicles they can’t fix or resell to the state of Tennessee, because it’s now easier to sell them there without worry.

 

Personally, I don’t believe this legislation will stand. Based on reactions from the citizens of Tennessee, my bet is that politicians will quickly repeal this legislation and claim they are “listening” to their constituents. Once that occurs, the only ones left looking like “bad guys” will be car dealerships, since this legislation was originally pushed through by the dealer association.

 

Perhaps there is a middle ground?

What if the legislation went a little further than simply notifying consumers? What if it added that the dealer would provide a full report about all existing recalls along with instructions on where to go for the necessary repairs?

 

If we took this extra step and notified consumers about any open safety recalls AND also provided instructions and guidance on how to get those repairs completed, it would be difficult for a consumer to then come back and sue the dealer.

 

Adding this dimension to legislation is just a common-sense measure. It would illustrate that dealers are doing everything in their power to instruct the customer; and that the customer is aware. It would be difficult for a consumer who did NOT follow the instructions to then argue that they should be able to sue the dealer.

 

Consumer perception is a huge problem for dealers. This type of legislation only further feeds into that negative image dealerships and manufacturers have been working hard to overcome. Instead of introducing legislation that seemingly only protects dealers, why not find a middle ground where everyone wins? 

Views: 39

Comment

You need to be a member of DealerELITE.net to add comments!

Join DealerELITE.net

Latest Activity

Terrel Watkins posted a blog post
yesterday
Scot Eisenfelder posted videos
yesterday
Jim Flint posted a blog post
yesterday
Bill Wittenmyer posted a video

Freebie Friday: Multitasking as a Myth

In this episode of Freebie Friday, CDK Global VP of Sales Bill Wittenmyer explains why multitasking is a myth.
yesterday
Jeff Cowan posted a blog post

Write Service Podcast: Episode 60- Can You Embrace Change?

This week's podcast is a LIVE snippet from a private workshop for an Automobile Dealer's…See More
Thursday
Andy Church posted a video

Profit By Action Quick Tip: Candidate Homework

In this Quick Tip, Andy Church shares a tip on an element that dealerships should include in their hiring process to improve productivity.
Thursday
Erik S. Nachbahr posted a video

Your Business Depends on a Reliable IT Infrastructure

Helion Founder & President Erik Nachbahr shares why a dealership's IT infrastructure is critical to its business in this video blog.
Thursday
Ujj Nath posted a blog post
Thursday
Samuel posted a blog post

Australia's Car Culture - A National Obsession, Observed

Australia is car-crazy. Always has been. For decades, the Holden-Ford argument has actually been a…See More
Wednesday
Tyler Newport posted a blog post

Is There Any Alternative for Wipers?

Windscreen wipers have played an important role in car design and safety for more than a century,…See More
Wednesday
Damian Boudreaux's blog post was featured
Wednesday
John Sternal posted a blog post

Auto Dealerships See Avg. 20% Rise in Profits Under DOWC

According to Protective Asset Protection, it is estimated that auto dealers leveraging a…See More
Tuesday
Black Book posted a blog post

Depreciation Rates Improve

Welcome to this week's edition of Black Book Market Insights, with in-depth analysis of used car…See More
Tuesday
Jim Flint posted a video

Website Taxes

Are you paying "tax" on your website to Google? CEO & Founder of Local Search Group Jim Flint explains in this video blog.
Tuesday
Damian Boudreaux posted a blog post
Tuesday
Simon Hopes posted a blog post

Getting Your Car Restored to Its Original Shine

Some of us may have had all good intentions of looking after our car when we first bought it. We…See More
Tuesday
Bobby posted a video

Bobby Compton ~ Motivational Listener

Moreover, look for able men from all the people, men who are trustworthy and hate a bribe, and place such men over the people as chiefs of thousands, of hund...
Monday
Bill Wittenmyer posted a video

Witt's Wise Words: Super Workers vs Supervisors

Bill Wittenmyer shares the difference between super workers and supervisors in this week's episode of Witt's Wise Words. To read the full article, click here...
Monday
Scot Eisenfelder's blog post was featured
Monday
Daniel Ross posted a blog post

Males's Socks - Picking Design and Comfort

The most fundamental of all men's devices, and the one utilized for convenience as well as style is…See More
Feb 17

Get Newsletter

© 2019   Created by DealerELITE.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service