Everyone is jumping up and down about "Social Media" and Online content/advertising....but is it really the benefit that it touts itself to be?? Here's a different point of view.

Reprinted from "The Ad Contrarian"

The Ad Contrarian is Bob Hoffman, ceo of Hoffman/Lewis advertising in San Francisco and St. Louis. Bob is former ceo of MOJO USA and ex-president and creative director of Allen & Dorward. He has served as president of the SF Ad Club and been on the board of AMIN, the Advertising and Marketing International Network.

The Failure Of Web Advertising

We're about 15 years into the internet revolution as a mainstream phenomenon and by any measure internet advertising has to be deemed a major failure.

While the web itself has been a massive success (influencing virtually every aspect of our lives) advertising on the web is mostly a bad joke.

Fifteen years into its mainstream life, television had created scores of powerful consumer-facing brands.

The only truly powerful brands I can think of that web advertising has created are native web brands like Google, Yahoo, Amazon and Facebook. It's as if the only brands television was good at creating were CBS, NBC and ABC.

After 15 years, can anyone name even ten serious non-native consumer-facing brands that have been created primarily by web advertising? Is there a brand of coffee, butter, beer, bread, chicken, gasoline, soda, peanut butter, dog food, milk, tires, potato chips, life insurance, lawn mowers...don't make me go on, you get the point...that has been built primarily by web advertising?

Display advertising is a joke. Remember just a few years ago when they were selling us banner ads on the promise that "interactivity" would make these ads so much more efficient than traditional ads? Then they started measuring them and found that fewer than 2 people in a thousand were clicking. Oops.

Now they're making the same lame "branding" argument for online display ads they made against traditional print ads.

Online video advertising is another joke. 99% of all video is currently watched on a tv, not a computer.

Social media is a rumor. Everybody is hyperventilating about it, but nobody has any idea of how you even measure success. Here are three links (one,  two, and three) to self-congratulatory videos of social media "experts" that run a total of almost 30 minutes.

In that 30 minutes I can't recall the word "sales" being mentioned even once. They're all about false goals: getting followers; creating "engagement"; creating "communities"; "re-organizing around the customer" and, of course, the ever-popular "blowing up silos." If you can get through this festival of smugness without contemplating suicide, you're a better man/woman/child/pet than I am.

These people are living in a different world.

I don't know about you, but if I walked into a meeting with one of my clients and told them that the purpose of the millions they're spending on advertising is to create "communities," they'd laugh me out of the room. They want sales and they want them now.

It is true that there's data to support the effectiveness of two types of online advertising: search and email. But is that it? Is that all the web is going to be? A medium of tactics? A Yellow Pages replacement and cheaper DM? How many powerful brands have been built by search and email? The answer: Zero.

Believe me, I'd love to see online advertising succeed. I'd love to have another forceful tool to help my clients succeed. But, like I've said before, online advertising is like communism. It's always going to be great some day, it's just never very good right now.

Impressionable advertisers are continuing to be sold more and more ...

http://adcontrarian.blogspot.com/2010/04/failure-of-web-advertising...

Views: 46

Reply to This

Latest Activity

Dave Anderson's blog post was featured

Four Steps to Productively Process Disappointment

Disappointments are a fact of life. The question isn't whether we'll experience them, but whether…See More
yesterday
Dave Anderson posted a blog post

Four Steps to Productively Process Disappointment

Disappointments are a fact of life. The question isn't whether we'll experience them, but whether…See More
yesterday
Sally Whitesell's blog post was featured
Tuesday
Bill Wittenmyer's video was featured

#WittsWiseWords: Do You Know What Your Competitors Are Doing

Scoping out your dealership competition is good business. Bill Wittenmyer says it can help you determine what prospects want that you currently aren't providing.
Tuesday
Simon Hopes posted a blog post

American Made New Ford Trucks for Sale!

This is a unique time in history because we are witnessing the rebranding of America on the global…See More
Monday
Bill Wittenmyer posted a video

#WittsWiseWords: Do You Know What Your Competitors Are Doing

Scoping out your dealership competition is good business. Bill Wittenmyer says it can help you determine what prospects want that you currently aren't provid...
Monday
Michael Trasatti posted a video

How to Work With Millennials

Mike Trasatti shares his thoughts about hiring and working with Millennials in this video blog.
Monday
Jim Flint posted a blog post
Friday
Sally Whitesell posted a blog post
Friday
Lehel Reeves posted a video

How Video Leads to More Sales

Lehel Reeves shares why consumers prefer video and how dealerships can lose sales if they fail to provide it.
Friday
Dave Anderson posted a blog post

Develop More Mental Toughness and Killer Instinct

No matter what level you're at, whatever your role, whatever your sport, if you're committed to…See More
Oct 10
Damian Boudreaux posted a blog post

Our Monthly Webcast

We’re back with…See More
Oct 10
DealerELITE posted a blog post
Oct 9
Bill Wittenmyer posted a video

#WittsWiseWords: Don't Let Your Ego Get in the Way of Your Paycheck

The best way to grow your team and grow your paycheck at the same time? In this edition of Witt's Wise Words, Bill Wittenmyer says keep your ego in check wit...
Oct 9
Dave Anderson posted a blog post
Oct 8
John Sternal posted a blog post

5 “Spooktacular” Lease Deals for Halloween

Swapalease.com Compiled 5 Most Reasonably Priced Automobile Leases Around the…See More
Oct 8
Scot Eisenfelder posted a video

Why Creativity Can Lead to More Service Revenue

Scot Eisenfelder explains how creativity can help dealers capture more service revenue from recalls.
Oct 4
Mike theCarGuy Correra posted a video

Are You Forgetting Your Dealership's Google My Business Page?

Account Manager Mike Correra explains why dealerships shouldn't neglect their Google My Business page in this video blog.
Oct 4

Get Newsletter

© 2019   Created by DealerELITE.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service