When Batman Decides a Recall Isn’t Enough

In 2014, due to safety concerns, Toyota issued a recall notice for a power inverter on its popular Toyota Prius. Nothing abnormal. But for the fact that, even after the recall was fixed, customers continued coming in with issues – hundreds of them – and that’s when Roger Hogan’s dealership decided enough was enough. According to an article on thedrive.com, he chose to voluntarily discontinue selling these models which resulted in an estimated $1 million worth of inventory parked on the lot. Roger was unwilling to sell these vehicles because he didn’t believe the recall fix would, in fact, make them safe for his customers.

 

Toyota responded, stating that the recall fix “lessens the likelihood of failure,” which simply wasn’t good enough for Hogan. He is adamant about keeping his customer’s safe. He voluntarily stopped selling these vehicles and, subsequently, filed a $100 million lawsuit against Toyota, claiming that the manufacturer failed to fix the problem. He also reached out to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

 

Hogan’s actions could be viewed as admirable in an industry that cannot afford to “sit on inventory.”  Hogan decided to do what he believes is the right thing by refusing to put his customer’s lives in jeopardy; risking a significant financial loss by sitting on inventory. The exact action no dealer ever wants to take. Yet, he did it voluntarily. Why?

 

According to Mr. Hogan, “A recall is supposed to prevent the incident from happening. It’s not supposed to be you fix it after you’ve experienced the horrific event, you’re supposed to prevent that event from ever occurring… Why should you be allowed to put someone’s life in danger?”

 

In this case, the dealer saw that the recall repair was NOT solving the problem and, rather than continuing to sell the vehicles, shelved them in the best interest of the consumer. Recalls are a multi-level problem involving the OEM, consumers, dealers and government agencies. Most cannot be simply solved just by a manufacturer issuing a fix. In a perfect world, that would be great. But, just like in our government, there is a checks and balances system that involves the manufacturers, dealers and, ultimately, the affected consumers. I am not suggesting that this is a solution for every dealer, I am just highlighting an interesting occurrence in our recall world, one that we can all perhaps learn from.

 

It’s clear that Hogan made a decision which he believed placed customer safety as a priority.  For that stance, it’s hard to be critical.  In fact, he has my respect. He refused to sell vehicles that he feels are unsafe, despite completing the required recall repair. The ultimate goal should be to ensure all vehicles consumers drive are safe for the sake of the vehicle owners and other drivers on the roads.  Did he do the right thing? The lawsuit will reveal whether Hogan went too far or if Toyota didn’t go far enough. Very interesting happenings going on.

 

For many consumer watchdog groups and dealers Hogan’s actions make him a figure of lore – a David among Goliaths, a superhero among Gotham’s villains.  And, sometimes, we need a Batman to stand up to the powers that be to make that happen.

Views: 28

Comment

You need to be a member of DealerELITE.net to add comments!

Join DealerELITE.net

dE Sponsor

Latest Activity

Todd Smith's blog post was featured
1 hour ago
Timothy Wilson posted a blog post
5 hours ago
Simon Hopes posted blog posts
9 hours ago
Black Book posted a blog post

Values Remained Stable Last Week

Welcome to this week's edition of Black Book Market Insights, with in-depth analysis of used car…See More
10 hours ago
Todd Smith posted a blog post
10 hours ago
Dave Benson's video was featured

What To Expect At Hustle & Grind

Hustle & Grind is a brand new automotive conference aimed at eradicating negative stigmas in the car business, and bringing innovation and disruption to our industry. Hustle & Grind 2018 just finished in Orlando Florida with over 500 people from…
13 hours ago
Cynthia Madison posted a blog post

Networking Events and How to Make the Most of Your Next One

Networking is essential and goes beyond the limits of the internet. Yes, you will need more than to…See More
13 hours ago
Kate Westall posted a blog post

Tips For Selecting The Best Auto Mechanic For Repairing Your Car

Like any other automotive machine, a car can also start showing problems any time and would require…See More
18 hours ago

de sponsor

Get Newsletter

dE Sponsor

© 2018   Created by DealerELITE.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service