Is Your Service Marketing Budget out of Whack?

Is your service marketing budget out of whack? And if so, what’s the right number? 

There is a clear misalignment between the service department’s contribution to store profits and the investment in service marketing.  According to NADA, service is responsible for 47.3% of dealership gross profits. However, working with dealers we estimate service marketing is <10% of the average dealership’s marketing budget. Why aren’t dealerships investing in marketing to support fixed operations?  

Look at these charts for a minute: 

Many of my dealer friends argue the chart is misleading because vehicle marketing indirectly drives service profits by setting up future warranty and customer pay opportunities. They feel that the alignment is not as bad as it seems.   

Well, I contend that the indirect relationship flows at least equally the other direction.  First, only half the service customers were sales customers. So, the indirect impact from sales is at best half.  More importantly, servicing owners are 1.5x more likely to remain loyal than non-servicing owners. In addition, loyal owners pay higher margins, providing the loyal sales base needed to sustain a store through challenging economic and product cycles.   

We can differ on which way the net arrow points.  But in my opinion, the indirect benefit from sales to service justifies a fresh look at this huge misalignment.  It rather represents a traditional mindset that service naturally flows from sales, and therefore requires only limited marketing encouragement.   

Given dealers only capture 25% of the service spend, the flow is not very natural. In addition, by most estimations, it is getting less certain as increased leasing places more vehicles in the hands of second owners that much earlier. And let’s not forget how independent service centers are increasingly competitive. 

So, what is the right number?  Actually, I don’t know.  Because we are so far from alignment, it is difficult to estimate the most economical place to stop.  However, can suggest a way to determine the right level over time.  I once had dinner with a former Expedia CMO and I asked, “How do online businesses determine their marketing budgets?”  He stated Expedia didn’t have an ad budget.  In astonishment, I stammered “What do you mean?” My friend explained, he kept spending, so long as each dollar of additional marketing spend yielded three dollars of revenue.   Pretty logical! 

So, what would this look like in our industry?  Many dealers are perfectly fine spending $300 on a TrueCar lead which yields at best $1,800 front and back gross.  Marketing spending across the industry per new vehicle sold was $630 in 2016; or 33of variable ops gross margin.  By this formula, you should be satisfied with an incremental service marketing spend that yields 10x in gross, up to $17k per month in service marketing. (The average dealer Service & Parts CP GP per month is $177k.) 

As a dealer, do you find it hard to image spending that much?  Well, isn’t that better than facing the harsh reality that stores continue to afford 75% service leakage as new and used vehicle margins continue to decline?

Views: 23

Comment

You need to be a member of DealerELITE.net to add comments!

Join DealerELITE.net

About

DealerELITE created this Ning Network.

Latest Activity

Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @SteveStauning: Checking out "Real Social Selling" on @dealerELITE: https://t.co/iE7DFKL8Ak
Twitter38 minutes ago · Reply · Retweet
Jeff Cowan posted a blog post

Write Service Podcast: Episode 45- The Holes in Your Process

This week, Jeff continues the discussion on having a true process on your service drive. Some of…See More
1 hour ago
Todd Smith posted a blog post
3 hours ago
Black Book posted a blog post

BLACK BOOK HISTORY ADJUSTED VALUATIONS NOW INTEGRATED INTO DIMONT’S CLAIMS ADJUSTMENT SYSTEMS

Vehicle Values With Historical Performance Can Greatly Increase Accuracy in Claims…See More
3 hours ago
Holly Markel posted a video

3 Keys to Developing Employees on the Phone (Part 2)

CallRevu Vice President of Customer Experience Holly Markel shares the first of three keys to developing your staff to handle the phones properly in part 2 o...
3 hours ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
Checking out "Real Social Selling" on @dealerELITE: https://t.co/kFUrawsfmT
Twitter3 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Steve Stauning's video was featured

Real Social Selling

If your salespeople aren't driving their own Up Bus, they're not doing everything they can to sell 20, 30 or even 40 units a month. Send them a link to this 49-minute lesson where they'll learn all they need to start generating real referrals from…
3 hours ago
John Sternal posted a blog post

August Auto Lease Prices Increase By Up To 54% On Several Vehicles

Several Brands Increase Lease Prices by up to 54% on Vehicles of All Sizes as New Model-Year Units…See More
4 hours ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
Dealer Elite Daily News is out! https://t.co/MhOb5gOdTN #automotivesales #carsales
Twitter4 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Steve Stauning posted a video

How To Sell Cars on Facebook: Real Social Selling

Originally recorded live as part of the Undeniable Advantage Live Video Webcast Series. Social Selling is real and it's happening today! Right now, dynamic, ...
4 hours ago
Thomas F. Jung posted a blog post
5 hours ago
Simon Hopes posted a blog post

Best Run about Boats For Family

If you are searching for a boat that is great for the whole family but it is also quite satisfying…See More
5 hours ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @Automotive_News: AutoNation's CEO says the industry is 'freaking out' about Trump's tariffs https://t.co/URPDxcvo0G https://t.co/PJ0znu
Twitter15 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @Automotive_News: Automakers offer financial assistance to victims of Hurricane Florence https://t.co/75nXpIRgtF https://t.co/EnE6fJq7Hm
Twitter15 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @dealerrefresh: Are OEM's forcing you to put codes in your website? - https://t.co/REZOnglx4U
Twitter15 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @SteveStauning: The Dreaded “Just Looking” – How to Overcome Objections on the Lot https://t.co/BovlxE8qhF #automotivesales #carsales #…
Twitter15 hours ago · Reply · Retweet

de sponsor

Get Newsletter

dE Sponsor

© 2018   Created by DealerELITE.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service