Jumpstart Automotive Media Unveils New Insights On Frustrations That Both Consumers & Dealers Face On Vehicle Pricing, Negotiations

Consumers Negotiate Because They Don’t Believe The Lowest Price Is Truly “The Lowest Price”

A full 86 percent of consumers already have a price in mind for the car they want before visiting the dealer to test drive or purchase a car or truck. This insight is courtesy of the latest study from Jumpstart Automotive Media and Ipsos: “Today’s Auto Buyer and the Digital Retailing Experience." The study, available by clicking here, addressed the distrust consumers have in vehicle pricing, and the frustrations many dealers encounter when trying to educate consumers on the pricing process.

Why A Pricing Disconnect Remains Between Consumers & Dealers

Eighty-one percent of consumers don’t believe a dealer’s “lowest price” and still expect to be able to negotiate savings of a few hundred to a few thousand dollars. At the same time, customers may not understand how cars are priced, which can lead to distrust and frustration on the dealer’s part. For example, there are often questions around whether the dealer or the manufacturer sets the price, what costs are built into that price, and what (if any) aspects does the dealer have the ability to negotiate. Consumers believe that dealers are making a large profit, while dealers today are saying that they don’t make money until they hit volume goals, which are often a challenge to reach.

Part of the challenge consumers feel comes from the fact that prices on many new vehicles today are at or near all-time highs. Americans remain attracted to large SUVs and trucks, and even when they’re interested in cars they want fully loaded with features or size and space for versatility. Approximately 49 percent of consumers say they determine a “fair” price based on what they find on third-party automotive websites, another 31 percent deem a vehicle to come with a fair price if there is a negotiated savings off the sticker.  

Is Negotiation Non-Negotiable?

Despite nine out of ten consumers having at least some interest in a “no-haggle” model for car buying, most still prefer to negotiate their own deal versus other ways of settling on a price. And, even though most agree that the sales process takes too long, they’re still willing to spend a half hour or longer bargaining to save even $100. What’s more, a consumer’s desire to negotiate their own deal vs. the no-haggling approach has more to do with a lack of trust with dealership pricing than a desire to bargain. Lastly, 68 percent of consumers say they would prefer to deal with a non-commissioned sales person at a dealership.

“The cat-and-mouse game of pricing and negotiation at the dealership won’t be fully satisfied any time soon,” said Libby Murad-Patel, vice president marketing and strategic insights for Jumpstart. “However, finding a true understanding of what each side is looking for will ultimately help in reducing the friction and adversarial nature when it comes down to vehicle pricing. Consumers can’t demand a no-haggle deal but ultimately want to try and save a few bucks, and dealers need to help consumers better understand how they arrived at a certain price point to build more trust.”

Click here to access the complete report.


Jumpstart commissioned Ipsos to conduct a comprehensive study into the consumer and dealer points of view. The study design included qualitative research consisting of a five-day online discussion with 28 U.S. consumers, a four-day online discussion with 28 dealers, and nine 60-minute phone interviews with dealership GMs and owners. Following these results, quantitative research was conducted in the form of online surveys of 263 recent buyers, in-market or intending car shoppers, and 54 dealership employees.

About Jumpstart

Jumpstart Automotive Media, a division of Hearst Autos, offers high-impact and performance-driven marketing and advertising solutions that achieve optimum results. An industry thought-leader known for its in-depth shopping reports, Jumpstart connects automotive marketers with the largest, high-performing audience of car shoppers and enthusiasts through partnerships with: Car and Driver, U.S. News Best Cars, J.D. Power Cars, NADAguides, Autoweek.com, Autobytel, Autolist.com, Daily News Autos, LeftLaneNews.com, CarSoup, CarBuzz, CarStory, VehicleHistory.com and iSeeCars.

JumpstartAuto.com, @JumpstartAuto

Views: 21


You need to be a member of DealerELITE.net to add comments!

Join DealerELITE.net

Latest Activity

Sally Whitesell posted a blog post
Eric Damiani posted a blog post


Cargurus, I have notice that because Carvana will provide free delivery to many area, they now show…See More
Bill Wittenmyer posted a video

Freebie Friday: How Do You Stay Motivated?

Bill Wittenmyer shares tips on how dealership personnel can stay motivated in this edition of Freebie Friday.
Andy Church posted a video

Profit By Action Quick Tip: Importance of Up To Date Warranties & Recalls

Andy Church shares why keeping up with warranties and recalls can increase profitability in this Quick Tip.
Scot Eisenfelder posted a video

Razor & Razor Blade Models for Dealerships: Part 1

Affinitiv CEO & Executive Chairman Scot Eisenfelder shares why dealerships should pay attention to the razor and razor blade models for their stores.
Jim Flint posted a blog post
Yogesh Sashi posted blog posts
Asad Shoaib posted a blog post

The Importance of Vehicle Electrical System Repair

The severity of the issue with your vehicle electrical system is dependent on the root causes and…See More
Ryan Holman posted a blog post

Let’s Know The Benefit Of Window Tint Films For Cars

Global warming has become a matter of concern nowadays. It has been showing its impact on the…See More
Walter McNulty posted a video


Big Event North Carolina
Walter McNulty posted a status
"Having a great event in North Carolina."
Veronica Dunford posted a blog post
Chris Miller posted a blog post
Erik S. Nachbahr posted a video

Is Your Computer Software Costing You Millions Due to Your Employees?

Erik Nachbahr explains why employees could be endangering dealerships through improper use of computer software.
Dave Anderson's 2 blog posts were featured
Anne Fleming's blog post was featured

How Did We Do?

As a part of your toolbox for improving the customer experience and reputation building, reviews…See More
Dave Anderson posted a blog post

The “Wow” is Worth It!

Author Joe Calloway described a “brand” well in his book Never by Chance: “A brand is defined as a…See More
Anne Fleming posted a blog post

How Did We Do?

As a part of your toolbox for improving the customer experience and reputation building, reviews…See More
Black Book posted blog posts

Get Newsletter

© 2019   Created by DealerELITE.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service